Top 5 Best 1911 Holster for Concealed Carry

Want to bring your 1911 firearm wherever you go? But don’t want to expose it?

Or maybe you’re looking for the most decent way to carry your gun like a law enforcer or a federal agent…

Well, you’ve come to the right place! We made a list of the Best 1911 Holster in the market today.

This article outlines their features and their attributes that make them stand out with the rest of the holster industry. 

Top 5 Best 1911 Holster on The Market

1. Kaylle Belly Band Concealed Carry Holster – Best Belly Band Holster for 1911

If you’re looking a comfortable holster to carry your 1911 on multi-purposes, the Kaylle Belly Band makes an ideal choice. 

The thing that makes it stand out in the competition lies on how it’s designed as a retention strap that utilizes a high-quality magnetic snap – instead of a metal snap or metal clip fastener.

The result is a virtually instant and quiet draw with the use of a single snap.


  • This one is made of superior quality neoprene material
  • Impressive attributes include micro-hole, anti-sweat, ventilated, comfortable, and lightweight design
  • Thin 2.5mm material for concealed and discreet carry
  • Elastic gun holder compatible with any pants, shorts, leggings, and even dresses


  • Ideal to wear for any activity – running, fitness, etc.
  • Retention uses magnetic snap as a high-quality replacement for a metal snap or metal clip fastener
  • check
    Allows you to carry in multiple positions based on how you feel, scenario you're in, what you're wearing.

There are a few user claims about how the Velcro material can have some issues, making this one not ideal for too large guns.

Overall, the Kaylle Belly Band Concealed Carry Holster is the solution for people looking for a guaranteed thin, concealed, comfortable holster that will fit most guns and can be purchased at an affordable price. 


  • check
    Comfortable enough to wear directly on the skin all day
  • check
    One size fit up to a 45" circumference
  • check
    Discreet and concealed; won’t show any signs
  • check
    Always ready and reliable for emergency purposes
  • check
    Will not fit with rail-mounted lasers


  • Will not fit with rail-mounted lasers
KAYLLE Belly Band Concealed Carry Holster - Neoprene Elastic Inside Waistband Gun Holster for Women...
330 Reviews
KAYLLE Belly Band Concealed Carry Holster - Neoprene Elastic Inside Waistband Gun Holster for Women...
  • GUARANTEE & FULL REFUND: We do not only sell products, we...
  • CONCEALED CARRY - Thickness 2.5 mm and discreet, Kaylle...
  • ONE SIZE FOR ALL: High quality neoprene material stretches...

Last Updated: 2018-07-16 at 23:33 PST - Details

2. Galco Combat Master Belt - Best 1911 Leather Holster

For people who love the classics, this leather belt holster with a brown finish might be the good-looking holster you’ve been looking for.

This one is made with imported, pure leather and composed of fine materials.

This makes an ideal companion for citizens, military, and law enforcers alike.

This one is from Galco – enough said. That fact alone should be enough to make you confident in using this one.

A minor problem – which is pretty common in almost all holsters – is experiencing a break-in time.

The Galco Combat Master Belt Holster for 1911 5-Inch Colt is the ideal solution for people looking for something made with the finest leather material.


  • Crafted with premium saddle leather, hand-molded fit, double-stitched seams to produce an impressive quality
  • Designed and available in both right and left-hand design; making it an ideal solution for people with specific drawing preferences
  • Designed to fit belts up to 1 ¾”


  • Tested for quality and durability so you can assure this one’s reliable in times of emergency
  • The Combat Master comes with an open top design, offering a smooth draw – swift enough to tackle sudden emergencies
  • check
    Detailed molding to ensure proper retention, open muzzle design


  • check
    Made of fine leather, Made in USA
  • check
    Double-stitched – a big plus!
  • check
    Can fit people with smaller bodies
  • check
    Butt forward design allows effective concealment for larger handguns


  • Depending on the user; needs a little time breaking it in
Galco Gunleather CM212 Combat Master Belt Holster for 1911 5-Inch Colt, Kimber, Para, Springfield...
250 Reviews
Galco Gunleather CM212 Combat Master Belt Holster for 1911 5-Inch Colt, Kimber, Para, Springfield...
  • Made using the finest materials
  • Used by law enforcement, military, and citizens alike
  • Tested for durability and quality
  • 1911 5-Inch Colt, Kimber, Para, Springfield

Last Updated: 2018-07-17 at 01:14 PST - Details

3. Relentless Tactical The Defender Leather - Best 1911 IWB Holster

If you’re looking for something that fits most 1911 style handguns but wins impressively at the comfort factor, the Relentless Tactical The Defender Leather IWB Holster might be the ideal choice for you.

This one can easily be your ultimate concealed carry holster “inside the waistband.”

You can fit any 1911 style handguns with this holster – the best part is you can fit any barrel length.

Arms examples that will fit include S & W, Kimber, Remington, Colt, Ruger, Browning, Sis Sauer, Taurus, and more.


  • Crafted with Genuine USA Bullhide Leather
  • Handmade by expert American Craftsmen; made in the USA
  • asterisk
    It won’t be hard for you to get a custom-made feel with this one


  • This one is not crafted with any synthetic material, consequently maximizing its performance
  • A reliable and sturdy holster you can depend in times of emergency
  • check
    Effective concealment and form fitted

One user suggested the holster to have a velvet inside as he claims his gun could get some scratches. However, the same user praised the holster for doing a great job.

Overall, The Defender Leather IWB Holster from Relentless Tactical offers you world-class quality and comfort without breaking the bank.

It’s backed by the brand’s lifetime warranty so you’ll be confident throughout.

The manufacturer guarantees free replacement if your handgun won’t fit, making this holster even more appealing for users especially those who are not sure if their weapon is compatible.


  • check
    Handmade and Built to last
  • check
    “Inside the waistband” concealed carry holster
  • check
    Impressive comfort
  • check
    With Lifetime Warranty


  • Minor claims of guns getting scratches
Relentless Tactical The Defender Leather IWB Holster - Fits Most 1911 Style Handguns - Kimber - Colt...
154 Reviews
Relentless Tactical The Defender Leather IWB Holster - Fits Most 1911 Style Handguns - Kimber - Colt...

Last Updated: 2018-07-17 at 01:15 PST - Details

4. Alien Gear Holsters Cloak Tuck 3.0 IWB Holster - Best Feature-packed Holster

Here comes the black beauty. The Alien Gear Holsters Cloak Tuck 3.0 needs no maintenance and zero break-in time. It has now been upgraded into the Cloak Tuck 3.5 IWB Holster with a tool-less design.

The Cloak Tuck 3.0 is an award-winning holster, offering superior performance in terms of concealment and comfort.

Readers of the Concealed Nation even dubbed this model as the “Best Holster in the History of Ever.”

Universal Shell system also available so you can be free to swap shells for varying models


  • This one is crafted with a flexible base and a formfitting neoprene
  • You can notice the ballistic nylon and spring steel; flexible material but never warps
  • asterisk
    Top surface crafted with a thermoelastic polymer, a proprietary attribute named as the Alien Skin
  • asterisk
    Built in such a way it requires zero break-in time


  • Adjustable retention – a big plus! With this one, you can set the draw of your preference
  • Adjustable belt clip – you can adjust this one for cant angle and ride height. This feature allows you to set the gun holster to the ideal carry position
  • check
    Universal Shell system also available so you can be free to swap shells for varying models

One user pointed out how the stitches can break around at the top. This is allegedly caused by the safety switch that can potentially cause wears.

Overall, the Alien Gear Holsters Cloak Tuck 3.0 IWB Holster can easily make itself as one of the best 1911 holsters to date. With outstanding features and competitive warranty, this one is hard to beat.

The brand even boasts their Iron Clad Triple Guarantee; a warranty system in which the user is given thirty (30) days to use the product and if unsatisfied, the manufacturer will buy the holster back.

Further, the brand also gives warranty to the holster for life. You can have your holster fixed as long as you have it. 


  • check
    Best feature-packed holster
  • check
    Comes with lots of features
  • check
    Easily concealable; Easy to wear
  • check
    Convenient clips
  • check
    Comes from a reputable brand, Lifetime warranty for fixes


  • Can possibly wear easily
Alien Gear Holsters Cloak Tuck 3.0 IWB Holster (Glock 19, Right)
1,406 Reviews
Alien Gear Holsters Cloak Tuck 3.0 IWB Holster (Glock 19, Right)
  • Notice* The Cloak Tuck 3.0 has been recently upgraded with a...
  • No maintenance or break-in time needed
  • Waterproof neoprene backpad
  • Lifetime warranty and 30-day trial period

Last Updated: 2018-07-16 at 21:55 PST - Details

5. Aker Leather 101 Comfort - Best 1911 Shoulder Holster For Law-Enforcers

Behold the most high-end holster on the list. The Aker Leather 101 Comfort-Flex Shoulder Holster is one of a kind.

This one is made with the finest vegetable-tanned cowhide materials.

The manufacturer boasts how this shoulder holster is used by federal agencies and law enforcers worldwide. 

This holster fits 1911 Government, Officer, and Commanded models with strong side safety and without rails only


  • Using the finest vegetable-tanned cowhide and raw materials
  • asterisk
    Made with high-quality materials from the USA


  • This one is designed with a specially contoured harness design
  • Can fit chest sizes up to 62” with the adjustable tension screws on the shoulder straps
  • check
    There are other styles including Glock 17/19, Beretta 92, S&W M&P 9/40/45, Glock 20/21, Springfield D and XD (M), and Sig Sauer P220/226/229

No rails and no dual safety fits – a minor con with this one. A user also reported how he doesn’t like the orientation of the gun – which pretty much depends on your preference.

Overall, the Aker Leather 101 Comfort-Flex Shoulder Holster is worth every penny spent.

This is the best 1911 holster for people looking for a decent and professional way to keep their firearms while on the move.


  • check
    High-end quality; high-end features
  • check
    Used by federal agencies
  • check
    Tested by law enforcers
  • check
    Made in the USA


  • Depending on the user, you may not like the gun’s orientation
Aker Leather 101 Comfort-Flex Shoulder Holster
25 Reviews
Aker Leather 101 Comfort-Flex Shoulder Holster
  • Made in the USA using the finest vegetable-tanned cowhide...
  • Tested and used by law enforcement and federal agencies...
  • Features a specially contoured harness design
  • Adjustable tension screws on the shoulder straps fit chest...

Last Updated: 2018-07-17 at 00:15 PST - Details

Leather vs Nylon – Which Material is Better for 1911 Holster?

Stuck in choosing between a leather-made and nylon-made?

There are lots of debates between nylon and leather about which one makes a better material in making a holster. 

But when you come to think deeply, it simply boils down to an individual’s preference.

If you’re the type of person who doesn’t know much about the two, this Leather vs Nylon segment might actually help you.


The best attribute of leather is being aesthetically pleasing. Also, leather has been recognized as a symbol of luxury and prestige in most products. Apart from the looks, leather makes an ideal holster material for the simple fact that it’s functional.

Leather holsters offer a nice and secure grip on your 1911. They are typically adjustable but not overly flexible.

That said, leather usually comes with limited holes for you to adjust the strap, making it capable of matching most sizes.

However, there are times you won’t be able to adjust to your exact length when your normal composition is between two sizes.

Leather holsters may require some time to break-in before you can utilize them properly.

You can minimize the break-in period by repeatedly drawing and holstering your handgun.


Nylon is cheaper but still a competitive alternative. You can expect affordable holsters to be made of nylon – but it doesn’t mean they are not sturdy.

This material also requires little-to-no maintenance and can retain its look after going through many things. You can throw it, even pour water on it, and it will still look new.

Nylon is versatile. The most flexible holsters are usually those made of nylon. This material is also highly adjustable; both right-handed and left-handed shooters can use the same model.

Ultimately, nylon holsters and comfortable and lightweight. So you can wear them for extended periods.


How to Choose The Best 1911 Holster?

If you’re stuck between choosing one model from another, this Best 1911 Holster Buying Guide might help you choose the right one for you.

You might want to weigh these factors to consider when buying one:


It’s a fairly good idea to settle with something made of genuine leather. If not, any other material can serve you well as long as the quality is ensured.

Remember that the holster’s material is the key factor affecting your comfort and its durability.

Leather: Lightweight, durable, and can offer good support for your handgun, leather stays to be the most popular material used by manufacturers to craft their holster masterpieces. 

Nylon: Lots of manufacturers are now turning into Nylon to make their holster models – and it’s a pretty good choice actually.

Nylon can offer multiple advantages that the leather material cannot. You can know more about the difference between nylon and leather in a comparison segment below this holster buying guide.


The most important factor probably is concealment. You might want something that fits securely underneath without everyone else noticing that you’re bringing a handgun with you.

Remember that its purpose is to give you defense whenever needed so there’s absolutely no need in exposing it. The material used also plays a role in the concealment factor.

Leather holsters are easy to conceal; although some leather holsters (like shoulder holsters) seem bulky sometimes.

If you want to wear a shoulder holster that comes with a magazine pouch, just make sure to place the holster and pouch in the same position. This prevents them from tangling.

Nylon holsters, on the other hand, are easier to conceal. You won’t need to wear a large jacket to hide the holster since a nylon-made fits more snugly to your body. Further, you can adjust the nylon to fit you better.

Concealment may not be the best attribute of shoulder holsters but you can easily hide them by wearing a jacket during the cold seasons.

Feel and Aesthetics

Leather can easily win on this aspect because this material is both functional and looks nice. In terms of aesthetics, leather holsters tend to be more superior to their nylon competitors.


Holsters come at different prices. While the cost determines how good the product is in other industries, the same principle may not always be true in the world of holsters. 


Finding the best 1911 holster is made easier with this list.

You basically don’t need to search the web and browse upon dozens, even hundreds of products to come up with some good prospects – we have done the job for you.

It all boils down to selecting one from the list of best 1911 holsters and start concealing your handgun for good.